For a long time, the idea that language might shape thought was considered at best untestable and more often simply wrong. Research in my labs at Stanford University and at MIT has helped reopen this question. We have collected data around the world: from China, Greece, Chile, Indonesia, Russia, and Aboriginal Australia. What we have learned is that people who speak different languages do indeed think differently and that even flukes of grammar can profoundly affect how we see the world. Language is a uniquely human gift, central to our experience of being human. Appreciating its role in constructing our mental lives brings us one step closer to understanding the very nature of humanity.
. . .
An important question at this point is: Are these differences caused by language per se or by some other aspect of culture? Of course, the lives of English, Mandarin, Greek, Spanish, and Kuuk Thaayorre speakers differ in a myriad of ways. How do we know that it is language itself that creates these differences in thought and not some other aspect of their respective cultures?
One way to answer this question is to teach people new ways of talking and see if that changes the way they think. In our lab, we've taught English speakers different ways of talking about time. In one such study, English speakers were taught to use size metaphors (as in Greek) to describe duration (e.g., a movie is larger than a sneeze), or vertical metaphors (as in Mandarin) to describe event order. Once the English speakers had learned to talk about time in these new ways, their cognitive performance began to resemble that of Greek or Mandarin speakers. This suggests that patterns in a language can indeed play a causal role in constructing how we think.6 In practical terms, it means that when you're learning a new language, you're not simply learning a new way of talking, you are also inadvertently learning a new way of thinking. Beyond abstract or complex domains of thought like space and time, languages also meddle in basic aspects of visual perception — our ability to distinguish colors, for example. Different languages divide up the color continuum differently: some make many more distinctions between colors than others, and the boundaries often don't line up across languages.
About Me
- my profiLe
- I still as a graduate student at the private university in Malang, And I wiLL try to do best in whereever n whenever I am,..
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(88)
-
▼
June
(8)
- Chicago, Duncan, tests
- On the uses and misuses of Advanced Placement - a ...
- How Does Our Language Shape the Way we Think?
- Ed Links and Other Unrelated Stuff
- The Secret to Success is Staying in School And Stu...
- Big Gains for Paying Kids to Do Well
- Effect of Recession on Future Education of Those W...
- The Perils of Public Scholarship
-
▼
June
(8)
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
How Does Our Language Shape the Way we Think?
from Edge, h/t neuroanthropology:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Category
- :) (1)
- "critical pedagogy" (1)
- "critical thinking" (2)
- "purpose of education" (1)
- "social justice" (1)
- 1960s (1)
- accountability (3)
- achievement (3)
- activism (1)
- administrators (1)
- Advanced Placement (1)
- Alinsky (1)
- all about eve (1)
- Anthony Mullen (1)
- Ariel Sacks (1)
- Arne Duncan Joel Klein (1)
- Barack Obama (1)
- Barnett Berry (1)
- bias (1)
- Broad Foundation (1)
- capitalism (3)
- charter schools (1)
- children (1)
- Christian vs. Muslim (1)
- citizenship (1)
- civic education (2)
- civil rights movement (1)
- cognitive (1)
- community empowerment (5)
- community engagement (2)
- community organizing (29)
- community school engagement (2)
- conservative (1)
- constitution (1)
- corporate vouchers (1)
- corporate welfare (1)
- corporations (1)
- culture (1)
- curriculum (1)
- Darling-Hammond (1)
- democracy (5)
- democratic education (2)
- Dewey (2)
- Diane Ravitch (3)
- Doug Christensen (1)
- Ed in '08 (1)
- Ed Royce (1)
- education (17)
- Education Nation (1)
- education organizing (4)
- education policy (3)
- education president (1)
- education reform (1)
- education reporting (1)
- educational equity (1)
- empirical (1)
- endowments (1)
- enlightenment (1)
- enviromental education (1)
- EPI Briefing Paper (1)
- ESEA (2)
- fear (1)
- federal policy (1)
- film (1)
- Finland (1)
- Finnish Schools (1)
- Fiscal Fairness Act (1)
- Fordham (1)
- foundations (2)
- foundations of education (1)
- funding (3)
- games (1)
- Gates Foundation (1)
- gender (1)
- George Will (1)
- GI Bill (1)
- global poverty (1)
- global warming (1)
- high scoring nations (1)
- high-stakes testing (3)
- Highly Effective Teachers (1)
- ideology (1)
- In the Trenches with School Reform (1)
- income gap (1)
- inequality (11)
- international conference (1)
- international development (1)
- international education (1)
- jessica (1)
- John Edwards - education proposal (1)
- John Holland (1)
- Jolynn Tarwater (1)
- Jose Vilson (1)
- Katherine Cox (1)
- Katy Farber (1)
- KIPP (2)
- labor (1)
- laptops (1)
- learning (1)
- learning theory (1)
- left-wing (1)
- liberal (2)
- Marion Brady (1)
- Mayoral Control (1)
- meliorism (1)
- militarization of schools (1)
- monthly forum (9)
- multiculturalism (1)
- multiple personalities (1)
- National Board Certification (2)
- NBC (1)
- NBPTS (1)
- NCLB (11)
- NCLB Effect (1)
- NEA (1)
- Nieman Foundation (1)
- nonprofits (1)
- NTOY (1)
- Ogbu (1)
- one laptop per child (1)
- one-to-one (1)
- Opportunity to Learn (1)
- parents (4)
- Pasi Sahlberg (1)
- performance pay (1)
- philanthropy (1)
- PISA (1)
- policy makers (1)
- politics (1)
- post-fordism (1)
- poverty (9)
- President Obama (1)
- progressive education (1)
- progressivism (1)
- ptsd (1)
- public and private (1)
- public education (1)
- public scholarship (1)
- questions (1)
- race (5)
- Race to the Top (1)
- rational (2)
- Renee Moore (1)
- Rep. Chaka Fattah (1)
- research (1)
- revolutions (1)
- Richard Rothstein (1)
- Robert Compton (1)
- Save Our Schools March and National Call to Action (2)
- school boards (1)
- school vouchers (2)
- schools (15)
- Schott Foundation (1)
- science (1)
- science and education (1)
- SDS (1)
- segregation (3)
- service learning (3)
- Shannon C'de Baca (1)
- simulations (1)
- single-sex education (1)
- sncc (1)
- social action (26)
- social class (13)
- social foundations (1)
- social justice (2)
- social movements (1)
- social science (1)
- stereotype threat (1)
- Student Bill of Rights (1)
- student test scores (1)
- students (1)
- teacher evaluation (1)
- Teacher Town Hall (1)
- teacher tr (1)
- teacherpreneurs (1)
- teachers (12)
- teaching (5)
- technology (2)
- testing (2)
- The Finland Phenomenon (1)
- think tanks (2)
- thinking (1)
- Title I (1)
- trauma (1)
- unions (5)
- urban (2)
- urban education (10)
- value-added assessment (1)
- vision (1)
- Westboro Baptist Church (1)
- Will Richardson (1)
- William Ayers (1)
- Wisconsin (1)
- xo (1)
No comments:
Post a Comment